Wage Theft Demand Letter
How to Calculate How Much Wage Theft You're Owed
Before you can recover stolen wages, you need to calculate how much you're owed. Learn how to compute unpaid overtime, minimum wage violations, and liquidated damages.
Recovering stolen wages requires knowing exactly how much you're owed. This calculation shapes your complaint, determines whether it's worth pursuing, and gives you a documented demand to present to the DOL or in court. Here's how to do the math for the most common types of wage theft.
At a Glance
Sections
6
FAQs answered
5
Reading time
5 min
Tool available
$39.99
Step 1: Establish Your Hours Worked Record
Your calculation is only as good as your time records. Gather or reconstruct:
Employer records you might be able to obtain:
- Old pay stubs (shows hours employer recorded)
- Time punch records or time card reports
- Email or text scheduling records showing when you were scheduled and required to be there
Your own records:
- Personal calendar entries showing work days and hours
- Text messages about schedule, being called in, start/end times
- Banking records showing payroll deposit dates and amounts
- Old screenshots of time tracking apps
When records don't exist: Courts allow employees to testify from memory about their typical work schedule and estimate hours. The burden then shifts to the employer to produce records proving otherwise. Employers who don't maintain proper records bear the risk of an employee's reasonable estimate being accepted.
Don't want to deal with this yourself?
Counter Gameplan's AI does the heavy lifting — analysis + ready-to-send letter in 60 seconds.
Calculating Unpaid Overtime
The overtime calculation:
- Determine your regular rate of pay: If your compensation includes only an hourly wage, that's your regular rate. If it includes non-discretionary bonuses or commissions, those must be added to the calculation.
- Calculate overtime hours: For each workweek, identify hours worked over 40.
- Calculate the overtime premium owed: Hours over 40 × (regular rate × 0.5) = overtime premium unpaid (you already received the base pay for those hours if paid hourly).
Example:
- Regular rate: $15/hour
- Hours worked: 50/week
- Overtime hours: 10
- Overtime rate: $15 × 1.5 = $22.50
- Overtime already paid: $0 (employer paid straight time for all hours)
- Overtime owed per week: 10 hours × $22.50 = $225; OR the overtime premium of 10 × $7.50 = $75 if you already received base pay for those 50 hours
- For 52 weeks: $75 × 52 = $3,900 unpaid overtime (premium only) OR $225 × 10 weeks = $2,250
Careful with the math: If you were paid your hourly rate for all 50 hours, you received the base portion of the overtime hours — you're just missing the 0.5× premium. If you were paid for 40 hours only and received nothing for the 10 overtime hours, you're owed 1.5× for all 10.
Calculating Minimum Wage Violations
Scenario 1 — Tipped employee below minimum wage:
- You received $2.13/hour cash wage + an average of $4.50/hour in tips = $6.63/hour effective wage
- Federal minimum: $7.25/hour
- Shortfall per hour: $0.62
- Hours worked: 35/week
- Weekly shortfall: $0.62 × 35 = $21.70
- Annual: $21.70 × 52 = $1,128.40/year
Scenario 2 — Illegal deduction reduces pay below minimum wage:
- You earn $7.25/hour for 40 hours = $290
- Employer deducts $50 for 'uniform'
- Net pay: $240
- Effective hourly rate: $240 ÷ 40 = $6.00/hour
- Shortfall per hour: $1.25
- Weekly shortfall: $1.25 × 40 = $50
- Annual: $50 × 52 = $2,600/year
Don't want to deal with this yourself?
Counter Gameplan's AI does the heavy lifting — analysis + ready-to-send letter in 60 seconds.
Adding Liquidated Damages to Your Calculation
The FLSA provides liquidated damages equal to the amount of back wages owed, unless the employer can show good faith compliance efforts.
What this means for your calculation: If you're owed $10,000 in back wages, your total potential recovery before attorney fees is $20,000.
When liquidated damages apply: In virtually all FLSA cases unless the employer shows:
- They acted in good faith
- Had reasonable grounds for believing they were complying with the FLSA
An employer who simply decided not to pay overtime, or who misclassified workers knowing they were employees, will not escape liquidated damages.
In state court: Many states have their own liquidated damage provisions — sometimes up to 3× back wages in egregious cases (New York's wage theft statute has provisions for up to 3× wages).
The Statute of Limitations and How It Affects Your Total
The FLSA allows you to recover back wages for:
- 2 years for non-willful violations
- 3 years for willful violations
'Willful' means: The employer knew their conduct violated the FLSA or showed reckless disregard for whether it did. An employer who deliberately misclassifies workers as exempt is almost certainly acting willfully.
How this affects your total:
- 2-year calculation: Take your weekly shortfall × 104 weeks
- 3-year calculation: Take your weekly shortfall × 156 weeks
Example:
- Weekly overtime unpaid: $225
- × 156 weeks (3 years, willful): $35,100 in back wages
- + $35,100 in liquidated damages
- Total: $70,200
This is a significant amount worth pursuing through a private lawsuit or DOL complaint.
Building a Demand Calculation Table
Create a table that will serve as your documentation for a complaint or demand letter:
| Period | Hours Worked | Hours Paid | Overtime Hours Unpaid | Regular Rate | Overtime Premium Owed |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Week 1 (Jan 1–7) | 48 | 40 | 8 | $15.00 | $60.00 |
| Week 2 (Jan 8–14) | 52 | 40 | 12 | $15.00 | $90.00 |
| ... | ... | ... | ... | ... | ... |
| Total | $X,XXX |
Plus liquidated damages: Total back wages × 1 = liquidated damages
Grand total: Back wages + liquidated damages
Include in your table: The methodology for calculating hours (how you know you worked those hours — time cards, texts, calendar, memory).
This table becomes the centerpiece of your DOL complaint or demand letter.
Still have questions? Read the FAQs below — or let the AI handle it for you →
Frequently Asked Questions
Quick answers to the most common questions on this topic.
Can I estimate hours if I don't have time records?
+
Yes. Courts and the DOL allow reasonable estimates of hours when employers fail to keep proper records. Your estimate should be as specific as possible — based on your typical schedule, manager instructions about when to start, and any corroborating evidence.
Do I include the cost of my time to pursue this claim in my damages?
+
Not as wage damages. Your time spent pursuing the claim isn't recoverable. However, if you hire an attorney, their fees are separately recoverable from the employer in a successful FLSA case — which is why these cases are taken on contingency.
My employer paid me in cash without stubs. How do I prove my rate and hours?
+
Use whatever records you have: bank deposits, texts about your rate and schedule, witness testimony from coworkers, and testimony about your typical schedule. The absence of employer records is itself evidence against the employer — the FLSA requires employers to maintain records.
What if I also have state law claims with different damage calculations?
+
File claims under both federal and state law. State laws often have longer statutes of limitations, higher damage multipliers, or additional remedies. A combined federal/state calculation maximizes your recovery.
Is it worth filing a complaint if the amount is small?
+
For small individual amounts — under a few hundred dollars — the practical calculation matters. A DOL complaint is free and worth filing regardless of amount. A private lawsuit requires finding an attorney willing to take it, which typically requires at least $5,000–$10,000 in potential damages (pre-liquidated damages) to justify the attorney's investment. Class actions change the calculus — your small claim combined with dozens of coworkers' similar claims becomes economically viable.