Small Claims Court Argument Builder
Collecting on a Small Claims Judgment: What Happens After You Win
Winning a small claims judgment is just the beginning. Learn how to collect through wage garnishment, bank levy, property liens, and other enforcement tools.
One of the most frustrating truths about small claims court: winning a judgment doesn't mean you get paid. The court won't collect money on your behalf — that's your job as the judgment creditor. About 40% of small claims judgments are never collected. But collection tools are powerful, and defendants who won't pay voluntarily often can be compelled to pay through garnishment, bank levies, or property liens. This guide walks through every collection method available.
At a Glance
Sections
6
FAQs answered
5
Reading time
6 min
Tool available
$29.99
The First Step: Registering and Recording Your Judgment
Before you can use any collection tool, ensure your judgment is properly recorded:
Record the judgment in your county: In most states, a small claims judgment becomes a lien on real estate when recorded with the county recorder's office. Recording fee: $10–$50. This prevents the defendant from selling or refinancing their home without paying you first.
Renew if necessary: Judgments expire. Most states allow judgments to be enforced for 5–10 years, but they must often be renewed before expiration. Check your state's renewal requirements.
Identify the defendant's assets: Before choosing a collection method, know what the defendant has:
- Are they employed? (wage garnishment)
- Do they have bank accounts? (bank levy)
- Do they own real estate? (property lien)
- Do they have other assets? (judgment debtor exam)
Wait the appeal period: Don't begin collection before the defendant's appeal period expires (typically 30 days). Collecting before that may give them grounds to complain to the court.
Wage Garnishment: The Most Effective Tool
Wage garnishment requires the defendant's employer to deduct money from their paycheck and pay it directly to you until the judgment is satisfied.
How it works:
- File a 'Writ of Execution' or 'Writ of Garnishment' with the court
- Have the writ served on the defendant's employer
- The employer begins deducting and remitting within 1–2 pay periods
Federal limits on garnishment (15 U.S.C. § 1673):
- Maximum: 25% of disposable earnings, OR the amount by which weekly disposable earnings exceed 30× the federal minimum wage ($7.25/hr = $217.50) — whichever is LESS
- Disposable earnings = gross pay minus legally required deductions
State limits: Many states have lower caps. California: 25% or excess over 40× minimum wage. Texas: 25% of disposable earnings.
Exemptions: Many types of income are exempt from garnishment: Social Security, disability, veterans benefits, pension benefits. You cannot garnish exempt income.
Finding the employer: If you don't know where the defendant works, you can use a judgment debtor examination to compel disclosure.
Bank Levy: Seizing Bank Account Funds
A bank levy (also called a bank attachment) instructs the bank to freeze funds in the defendant's account and pay them to you.
How it works:
- Obtain a Writ of Execution from the court
- Identify the defendant's bank (you may need a judgment debtor exam for this)
- Have the writ served on the bank's legal department
- The bank freezes available funds (up to the judgment amount) immediately
- After a holding period (usually 30 days) for any exemptions to be claimed, funds are released to you
The timing issue: Bank levies only capture what's in the account on the date of the levy. If the account is empty, you get nothing. Multiple levies may be needed if the defendant has sporadic income.
Exempt funds: Federal and state law protect certain deposits: direct-deposited Social Security (bank must protect 2 months' worth), SSI, veterans benefits, pension payments.
Practical tip: The best time to levy is right after a direct deposit (typically the 1st or 15th of the month). Serve the writ to arrive at the bank on those dates.
Judgment Debtor Examination: Getting Information
If you don't know what the defendant owns or where they bank, the judgment debtor examination (also called a debtor's exam or supplemental proceedings) is your discovery tool.
How it works:
- File a request for a debtor examination with the small claims court
- The court orders the defendant to appear for questioning under oath
- You ask questions about their finances: employer, bank accounts, real estate, vehicles, retirement accounts
- You can subpoena bank records, pay stubs, or other financial documents
What you can ask:
- Where do you work? What is your employer's address?
- What banks do you use? What are your account numbers?
- Do you own real estate? What is the address?
- What vehicles do you own?
- Do you have any pending lawsuits where you're a plaintiff (potential award to collect from)?
- Do you have business interests or accounts receivable?
Failing to appear: If the defendant ignores a court order to appear for the debtor exam, they can be held in contempt of court. The court can issue a bench warrant for their arrest.
Cost: Typically $25–$75 to file for the examination.
Property Liens: The Long Game
When a judgment is recorded as a lien on real property, you're paid when the property is sold or refinanced — which may be years away but eventually happens.
Recording the lien:
- In most states, a certified copy of the judgment recorded with the county recorder creates a lien on any real property the defendant owns in that county
- Recording fee: $10–$50
- The lien shows up on title searches
How you get paid: When the defendant tries to sell or refinance, the title company discovers your lien. The transaction cannot close without your lien being satisfied. The closing agent contacts you for the payoff amount, which includes accrued interest.
Interest on judgments: Most states allow judgment interest to accrue, typically at 5–10% per year. A $5,000 judgment in a state with 7% interest accrues $350/year. Document accrued interest carefully.
Judgment to multiple counties: If the defendant owns property in a different county, record the judgment there too. In many states, you need a 'sister judgment' or to re-record in each county.
When liens don't work: If the property is underwater (owed more than it's worth), your lien may be worthless. If the property is a homestead and your state has a homestead exemption, the exemption may protect it.
When the Defendant Files for Bankruptcy
Bankruptcy can disrupt your collection efforts:
Automatic stay: When the defendant files for bankruptcy, an automatic stay immediately stops all collection efforts — garnishments must stop, levies must stop, lien enforcement stops.
Chapter 7 vs. Chapter 13:
- Chapter 7: Most debts discharged. Your unsecured judgment debt is likely dischargeable.
- Chapter 13: Repayment plan. You may receive partial payment through the plan.
Non-dischargeable debts: Judgments based on fraud, intentional torts, or certain other conduct may survive bankruptcy. If your judgment was based on fraud or intentional harm, consult an attorney about filing a non-dischargeability complaint.
Filing a proof of claim: When the defendant files bankruptcy, you should receive notice. File a Proof of Claim in the bankruptcy proceeding to ensure you're in line to receive any distribution.
The practical outcome: Many small claims judgment debtors who file bankruptcy are truly insolvent — you may not recover your judgment even after the bankruptcy. This is an unfortunate reality of judgment collection.
Frequently Asked Questions
Quick answers to the most common questions on this topic.
How long can I try to collect a small claims judgment?
+
Most states give you 5–10 years to enforce a judgment, with the ability to renew. California: 10 years, renewable. New York: 20 years. Texas: 10 years. Check your state's specific period and renewal procedure. Don't let the judgment expire without attempting renewal.
Can I garnish a self-employed defendant's income?
+
Not through wage garnishment (which requires an employer). However, you can levy their business bank accounts, lien their property, and potentially garnish payments they receive from clients under a bank levy or assignment order. Self-employed debtors are harder to collect from but not impossible.
What if the defendant lives in a different state?
+
You may need to register your judgment in the defendant's home state (called 'domesticating' the judgment) to use that state's collection tools. Most states will register judgments from other states through a relatively simple process. You then use the new state's garnishment and levy tools.
Can the defendant be imprisoned for not paying a small claims judgment?
+
Not for the debt itself — debtor's prisons were abolished. However, a defendant can be held in contempt of court for ignoring a court order (like a debtor examination order) and potentially jailed for that contempt. The threat of contempt proceedings can motivate payment.
Is interest added to my judgment automatically?
+
In most states, statutory post-judgment interest accrues automatically from the judgment date. Rates vary: California 10%/year, New York 9%/year, Texas 5.5%/year. You don't need to do anything for interest to accrue, but you do need to calculate and document the total (principal + interest) when collecting.