Insurance Claim Denial Fighter
Using the Appraisal Clause to Resolve Insurance Disputes Without Going to Court
Most property insurance policies include an appraisal clause that lets you resolve valuation disputes outside of court. Learn how to invoke it, what to expect, and when it applies.
If you and your insurance company agree that a loss is covered but disagree about how much it's worth, you may be able to bypass lengthy litigation through your policy's appraisal clause. This binding process is faster and cheaper than a lawsuit, and it's specifically designed for valuation disputes. Most policyholders don't know this right exists.
At a Glance
Sections
6
FAQs answered
5
Reading time
6 min
Tool available
$79.99
What Is the Insurance Appraisal Clause?
Most property insurance policies (homeowners, commercial property, auto comprehensive/collision) include an appraisal clause in the conditions section. It provides a private dispute resolution mechanism when the parties agree a loss is covered but disagree on the amount.
A typical appraisal clause reads:
'If you and we fail to agree on the amount of loss, either may demand an appraisal of the loss. In this event, each party will choose a competent and impartial appraiser within 20 days after receiving a written request from the other. The two appraisers will choose an umpire. If they cannot agree upon an umpire within 15 days, you or we may request that the choice be made by a judge of a court of record in the state where the residence premises is located. The appraisers will separately set the amount of loss. If the appraisers submit a written report of an agreement to us, the amount agreed upon will be the amount of loss. If they fail to agree, they will submit their differences to the umpire. A decision agreed to by any two will set the amount of loss.'
The key conditions: both parties must agree coverage exists, and the dispute is about the dollar amount of the loss.
When Appraisal Is the Right Tool
Appraisal is appropriate when:
- The insurer agrees the damage is covered but disputes how much the repair/replacement costs
- You and the insurer have different contractor estimates
- The insurer's scope of repairs is incomplete (missing items you believe are damaged)
- You disagree on actual cash value vs. replacement cost calculations
- Business interruption disputes over the amount of lost income
Appraisal is NOT appropriate when:
- The insurer is denying coverage entirely (no coverage = no amount to appraise)
- The dispute is about the cause of loss (was it flood or wind?)
- The insurer claims fraud or intentional misrepresentation
- There are policy conditions questions (did you give timely notice?)
The line between 'coverage' disputes and 'amount' disputes can be blurry. Courts in some states allow appraisal to resolve what might seem like coverage questions if the underlying dispute is really about how much damage a covered peril caused.
How to Invoke the Appraisal Clause
Step 1 — Review your policy: Find the appraisal clause in the Conditions section. Note the timeframes, requirements, and any specific language about how appraisers must be 'competent and impartial.'
Step 2 — Send written demand: Send a formal written demand for appraisal to the insurer. Your letter should:
- Reference the specific policy and claim number
- State that the parties are unable to agree on the amount of loss
- Formally invoke the appraisal clause under the policy
- Notify the insurer of your chosen appraiser (you can name them in the demand letter or within the timeframe specified)
Send via certified mail, return receipt requested.
Step 3 — Select your appraiser: Your appraiser must be 'competent and impartial' — which typically means they cannot have a financial stake in the outcome. Public adjusters sometimes serve as appraisers. Contractors can in some states, though their independence may be questioned.
Step 4 — Umpire selection: If your appraisers can't agree on an umpire, a court can appoint one on application by either party.
Selecting Your Appraiser
Your choice of appraiser is the most important decision in the appraisal process. A skilled, credible appraiser increases the likelihood of a favorable umpire decision.
Appraiser qualities to look for:
- Licensed public adjuster or certified appraiser
- Specific experience with your type of loss (water damage, fire, hail, etc.)
- Experience specifically in the appraisal process — different from general adjusting work
- No direct financial interest in the claim outcome (which would make them biased, and the insurer will challenge this)
- Good documentation skills — appraisers who can prepare detailed, organized exhibits are more persuasive
Who shouldn't serve as your appraiser:
- Your original contractor (they have a financial interest in a higher estimate)
- Anyone who already performed work on the property for this claim
- Family members or close friends
Ask candidates how many appraisal proceedings they've participated in and their experience going to umpire.
What Happens at Appraisal
The appraisal process is less formal than litigation but follows a structure:
- Both appraisers independently assess the scope and value of the loss
- They exchange their estimates and try to agree on an amount
- If they can't agree, the dispute goes to the umpire
- The umpire (often a former insurance professional, engineer, or attorney) reviews both appraisers' work and decides
- The umpire's decision, agreed to by at least one appraiser, becomes the binding award
Timeline: Appraisal typically takes 60–120 days from demand to award, compared to 1–3 years for litigation.
Binding nature: The appraisal award is binding on the parties (subject to very limited court review for fraud or misconduct). You give up the ability to later argue for a higher amount, but you get finality.
Costs: Each party pays their own appraiser. The umpire's fee is usually split equally between the parties. Umpire fees vary widely ($2,000–$10,000+).
Can the Insurer Refuse to Participate in Appraisal?
If you invoke the appraisal clause and the insurer refuses to participate, you may be able to compel appraisal through a court order (petition to compel appraisal).
Most courts readily compel appraisal when the policy contains an appraisal clause and the insurer refuses to participate without good cause. This is a faster and cheaper court action than full litigation — often resolved in weeks.
Insurers sometimes resist appraisal by arguing the dispute is a 'coverage question' not an 'amount question.' In these situations, a court may need to decide whether appraisal is appropriate before ordering it to proceed.
Bad faith implications: An insurer's refusal to participate in a properly invoked appraisal process may itself constitute evidence of bad faith claims handling.
Frequently Asked Questions
Quick answers to the most common questions on this topic.
Is the appraisal process available in all states?
+
Most states recognize appraisal clauses in insurance policies and courts readily enforce them. Some state laws specifically address appraisal. The exact process and timeframes in your specific policy control.
Can I use the appraisal clause for a health insurance claim?
+
No. The appraisal clause is specific to property and casualty insurance. Health insurance disputes use separate appeal and external review processes.
What if I'm not happy with the appraisal award?
+
Appraisal awards are binding with very limited court review — only fraud, collusion, or misconduct can void an award. If you have concerns about your appraiser's competence, address them before the award, not after.
Does invoking appraisal stop the statute of limitations on my claim?
+
In many states, invoking appraisal tolls (pauses) the suit limitation period during the appraisal process. Confirm this for your state — if it doesn't toll, you may need to file a protective lawsuit while appraisal proceeds.
Can I use a public adjuster as my appraiser?
+
In most states, yes — public adjusters commonly serve as appraisers. Some policies or courts have found public adjusters who worked on the original claim to have a financial interest. For the appraisal, choose a PA who was not involved in the original claim adjustment.