Nursing Home Neglect Complaint
Nursing Home Arbitration Clauses: What They Mean and How to Fight Back
Many nursing homes require arbitration agreements that waive your right to sue. Learn whether these clauses are enforceable, your right to refuse, and how to challenge them.
Buried in nursing home admission paperwork — often signed under duress, when a family is rushing to get a loved one placed after a hospital stay — is frequently an arbitration agreement that waives the resident's right to a jury trial for any dispute, including abuse and neglect claims. These clauses are deeply controversial, and federal regulators have repeatedly attempted to restrict them. Understanding your rights around nursing home arbitration clauses can preserve your family's most important legal remedy.
At a Glance
Sections
6
FAQs answered
5
Reading time
6 min
Tool available
$79.99
What Nursing Home Arbitration Clauses Do
An arbitration clause in a nursing home admission agreement typically requires:
- All disputes between the resident and facility to be resolved through private arbitration
- Waiver of the right to a jury trial
- Selection of an arbitration provider (usually the American Arbitration Association or similar)
- Agreement to be bound by the arbitrator's decision
- Often: confidentiality of the proceeding and outcome
The practical effect for families: if your loved one is harmed by neglect or abuse, you cannot sue in court. You must go to private arbitration — a process with limited discovery, no jury, and historically lower awards for plaintiffs than court verdicts.
For nursing homes, arbitration is highly favorable: they appear before the same arbitrators repeatedly (repeat player advantage), arbitrators have lower plaintiff win rates than juries, awards are typically lower than jury verdicts, and the confidentiality provisions prevent public awareness of recurring abuse issues at specific facilities.
The CMS Arbitration Rule: A Continuing Legal Battle
CMS has attempted multiple times to restrict nursing home arbitration clauses:
2016 CMS Rule: Prohibited pre-dispute arbitration agreements as a condition of admission to Medicare/Medicaid-certified facilities. Industry challenged this rule.
2017 Revision: CMS revised the rule to allow arbitration agreements but require specific consumer protections:
- Agreements cannot be a condition of admission — residents must have an independent choice to sign
- Must be written in plain language
- Must explain the right to not sign
- Must be signed after admission, not as a condition
- Must be prominently displayed and explained
- Must name a venue in the state where the facility is located
Current status: The 2019 rule (84 Fed. Reg. 34718) is in effect, allowing arbitration agreements with these conditions. However, any agreement that doesn't comply with these conditions may be challengeable.
States can still impose their own restrictions — California, for example, has additional requirements for nursing home arbitration agreements under Health & Safety Code § 1430.
Your Right to Refuse
Under the current CMS regulation, a nursing home cannot make an arbitration agreement a condition of admission. This is the most important thing to know.
You can:
- Refuse to sign the arbitration agreement
- Cross out and initial the arbitration clause while signing the rest of the admission paperwork
- Request that the arbitration agreement be removed from the admissions documents
- Accept the room and begin care without signing the arbitration agreement
The facility cannot:
- Refuse to admit the resident because you won't sign the arbitration agreement
- Discharge the resident because you refuse to sign
- Condition the level of care on signing the arbitration agreement
Practical reality: Admissions coordinators may pressure you to sign 'standard' paperwork, may not explain that the arbitration clause is optional, or may try to make it seem like the whole package is a take-it-or-leave-it condition. Know your rights. Say clearly: 'We will not be signing the arbitration agreement. We understand this cannot be a condition of admission under federal law.'
Put your refusal in writing — a short email: 'This confirms that we did not sign and will not sign the arbitration agreement included in the admission packet.'
Challenging Existing Arbitration Agreements
If your family member or you already signed an arbitration agreement, it's not necessarily bulletproof:
Procedural challenges:
- Was the agreement signed as a condition of admission (the prohibited practice)?
- Was the resident given proper notice and explanation of the right to refuse?
- Was it signed in plain language?
- Was it signed by the resident themselves, or by a family member without proper legal authority?
Capacity challenges: If the resident lacked the cognitive capacity to understand and consent to arbitration at the time of signing — as is the case with many dementia patients — the agreement may be void. An adult guardian or duly appointed healthcare proxy would need to have signed on the resident's behalf.
Unconscionability: Courts can refuse to enforce arbitration agreements they find procedurally or substantively unconscionable. Procedural: signed under emergency circumstances with no explanation. Substantive: severely one-sided terms.
State law challenges: Some states have additional requirements for nursing home arbitration agreements. California's requirements are stricter than federal minimums. Check your state's specific rules.
Consult an elder law or nursing home negligence attorney before accepting that an arbitration agreement defeats your case.
When Arbitration Applies vs. When It Doesn't
Even a valid arbitration agreement doesn't prevent all legal remedies:
Arbitration applies to: Civil negligence and wrongful death claims between the resident/estate and the facility.
Arbitration does not apply to:
- Criminal prosecution of abusive staff members
- State survey agency investigation and enforcement
- CMS regulatory actions, penalties, and decertification
- Adult Protective Services investigations
- Claims under the Elder Justice Act or state elder abuse statutes with independent enforcement mechanisms
- Class action claims (many nursing home cases have been certified as class actions even with individual arbitration agreements)
- Claims against individual staff members who aren't covered by the facility's arbitration agreement
Filing complaints, triggering regulatory investigations, and criminal referrals remain fully available regardless of any arbitration agreement. For many families, regulatory action and a formal complaint are more satisfying remedies than litigation anyway — they result in changed practices and public accountability, not just money.
If You're Forced Into Arbitration
If arbitration is enforced, you can still achieve a fair outcome with the right approach:
Choose your arbitrator carefully: In AAA and JAMS arbitrations, parties select arbitrators from a panel. Research each candidate's history — win rates for claimants vs. respondents, any bias indicators, healthcare background.
Use discovery rights: Even in arbitration, you're entitled to discovery — depositions, document requests, expert witnesses. Don't accept a process that denies reasonable discovery.
Hire an experienced elder law attorney: Nursing home arbitration is a specialized practice area. An attorney who regularly handles nursing home claims in arbitration knows the process, the arbitrators, and how to achieve fair results.
The scope issue: Check whether the arbitration clause actually covers your specific claim. Some clauses are written broadly; others have exclusions. If your claim falls outside the clause's scope, you can argue for court proceedings.
Confidentiality: If there's a confidentiality clause, an attorney can sometimes negotiate a carve-out allowing the family to share information about the outcome.
Frequently Asked Questions
Quick answers to the most common questions on this topic.
Can I cross out the arbitration clause and still admit my family member?
+
Yes. Under 42 C.F.R. § 483.70(n), nursing homes cannot make arbitration agreements a condition of admission. Cross out the arbitration clause, initial it, and note on the signature line that you refuse to consent to arbitration. Keep a copy. If the facility refuses admission based on this, that's a federal violation.
What if my family member signed the arbitration agreement without consulting me?
+
It depends on whether they had authority to bind the resident and whether they had capacity. A family member without legal authority (no healthcare proxy, no guardianship) may not have had the legal right to sign on the resident's behalf. Consult an attorney about whether the agreement is enforceable given how it was executed.
Does a nursing home arbitration clause cover the wrongful death of a resident?
+
Potentially yes, if written broadly enough and properly executed. However, wrongful death claims are brought by the estate or heirs, who may not be bound by an agreement they didn't sign. This is a jurisdiction-specific question that an attorney must evaluate for your specific case.
Are arbitration awards public?
+
Typically no. This is one of the most objectionable features of nursing home arbitration — when a facility repeatedly abuses or neglects residents and pays confidential settlements, the public has no notice of the pattern. Some states are pushing for public reporting of nursing home arbitration outcomes.
Can a nursing home arbitration agreement prevent a wrongful death lawsuit?
+
It can create a strong legal argument for requiring arbitration. Whether it succeeds depends on state law, how the agreement was signed, capacity issues, and whether it complies with all CMS requirements. This is why consulting an elder law attorney immediately after a serious incident — before doing anything that could waive additional rights — is essential.