Security Deposit Demand Letter
Pet Deposits, Pet Fees, and Pet Rent: What Landlords Can Legally Charge
Pet deposits, fees, and rent are legally distinct — with different rules for refundability and caps. Learn what landlords can charge for pets and what protections exist for ESA owners.
Landlords can charge more for pets — but there are rules about how much, what's refundable, and how it's structured. The three types of pet charges (deposit, fee, rent) have different legal treatment. And if you have an emotional support animal or service animal, different rules may apply entirely. Here's the complete breakdown.
At a Glance
Sections
5
FAQs answered
5
Reading time
6 min
Tool available
$39.99
Pet Deposit vs. Pet Fee vs. Pet Rent: The Key Distinctions
Landlords use these terms loosely, but they have distinct legal meanings:
Pet Deposit: A refundable amount (like a regular security deposit) held as security against pet-caused damage. If there's no pet damage at move-out, the pet deposit must be returned.
- Refundable: Yes
- Subject to security deposit return deadline: Yes (in most states)
- Can be deducted for: Pet-caused damage only (not general damage)
Pet Fee: A one-time, non-refundable charge paid for the privilege of having a pet. Not a deposit — it's never returned regardless of how well the pet behaved.
- Refundable: No
- Amount: Whatever landlord sets (subject to state caps if any)
- Deductible for damage: No — a fee isn't held against damages; it's just a charge
Pet Rent: An ongoing monthly add-on to the base rent for having a pet.
- Refundable: No (it's rent)
- Amount: Landlord's discretion (typically $25-$75/month)
- Deductible for damage: No
Why the distinction matters: If your lease calls something a 'pet deposit,' it's refundable and subject to security deposit return laws. If it's labeled a 'pet fee,' it's non-refundable. Make sure you know which type you paid — and get the distinction in writing.
Don't want to deal with this yourself?
Counter Gameplan's AI does the heavy lifting — analysis + ready-to-send letter in 60 seconds.
State Caps on Pet Deposits
Some states limit how much landlords can charge in total (including pet deposits) or cap pet deposits specifically:
States with overall deposit caps (pet deposit included):
- California: Total deposits limited to 2 months' rent (unfurnished) or 3 months' rent (furnished). Pet deposit counts toward this cap.
- Washington: No statutory cap but courts may scrutinize excessive deposits
- Massachusetts: Security deposit limited to one month's rent; separate pet deposits may be restricted
Pet-specific deposit rules:
- California: Pet deposit is refundable; combined with security deposit, cannot exceed 2 months' rent
- Oregon: Landlords can charge a pet deposit but it's fully refundable
- Many states: No specific cap on pet deposits if they don't exceed overall deposit limits
Non-refundable pet fees: Non-refundable fees are permitted in most states as long as they're clearly labeled as non-refundable in the lease and aren't disguised as refundable deposits. California is an exception — California's security deposit law doesn't recognize non-refundable fees of any kind.
Practical advice: When you move in:
- Get every pet charge documented in writing (deposit vs. fee vs. rent)
- Ask explicitly: 'Is this refundable?'
- Get the answer in the lease language, not just verbally
Charging for Pet Damage at Move-Out
Pet damage at move-out is handled similarly to tenant damage, with important distinctions:
What counts as pet damage (vs. pet wear and tear):
- Pet damage: Visible chew marks on trim, claw scratches into hardwood floors, urine stains in carpet (requiring replacement), holes in screens
- Normal pet-related wear: Minor floor scuffing from pet claws (if not deeply scratched), light wear of carpet from pet traffic
The smell question: Pet odor is a significant issue. Strong urine odor that requires special treatment, ozone cleaning, or carpet replacement is generally chargeable. Mild odor that dissipates with normal cleaning is closer to normal wear. The distinction comes down to cost and whether extraordinary measures are required.
If you paid a pet deposit: The pet deposit is applied to pet-caused damage first. Any remaining pet deposit is returned. If pet damage exceeds the pet deposit, the security deposit covers the excess.
If you paid a non-refundable pet fee: The fee is gone regardless. Pet damage is still charged against your security deposit. Some tenants believe paying a pet fee means they won't be charged for pet damage — this is wrong. The fee is not insurance against damage; it's a payment for the privilege of having the pet.
Don't want to deal with this yourself?
Counter Gameplan's AI does the heavy lifting — analysis + ready-to-send letter in 60 seconds.
Emotional Support Animals and Service Animals: Different Rules Apply
If you have an emotional support animal (ESA) or service animal, landlords generally cannot charge pet deposits or fees:
Service Animals (ADA):
- Landlords cannot deny housing to people with service animals
- Cannot charge pet deposits, fees, or additional rent for a service animal
- Can charge for actual damage caused by the service animal (but no fee merely for having the animal)
Emotional Support Animals (Fair Housing Act):
- Landlords must provide reasonable accommodations for ESAs, including allowing them in no-pet housing
- Cannot charge pet deposits or fees for ESAs in residential housing
- Can charge for actual damage caused by the ESA
ESA documentation: To request an ESA accommodation, you typically need a letter from a licensed mental health professional (therapist, psychiatrist, psychologist) stating that you have a disability and that the ESA provides support for that disability.
Limits on the ESA exemption:
- The animal must not pose a direct threat or cause fundamental alteration of the housing
- The exemption applies to fees and deposits — not to other lease terms
- Landlords can request documentation but cannot require specific forms or medical records
Common landlord violations:
- Charging a pet deposit for an ESA despite receiving ESA documentation
- Refusing to return the pet deposit after receiving documentation of ESA status
- Demanding excessive documentation to verify ESA status
If your landlord is violating these rules, file a complaint with HUD (hud.gov/fair_housing) and consult a tenant rights attorney.
Move-Out Strategy for Pet Owners
Pet owners face higher scrutiny at move-out. Protect your deposit with these strategies:
Before move-out:
- Professionally clean carpets (get the receipt)
- Address pet odor with an enzymatic cleaner (not just air freshener)
- Repair minor pet scratches in wood with a matching wood filler
- Clean pet hair from all surfaces, vents, and filters
- Replace HVAC filter if it's loaded with pet hair
Document your efforts: Keep receipts for any professional cleaning, deodorizing, or repairs. If your landlord claims $500 in pet cleaning but you can show you paid $200 for professional cleaning that left the unit in normal condition, the landlord's additional $300 charge is harder to justify.
Move-out photos: Take comprehensive photos showing carpet condition (including edges where staining concentrates), floor condition, walls at pet height, and any areas where your pet spent significant time.
Dispute false pet damage claims: If your landlord charges for 'pet damage' that was actually pre-existing or normal wear, dispute it the same way as any other improper charge — move-in photos showing the pre-existing condition, and move-out photos showing similar condition.
Still have questions? Read the FAQs below — or let the AI handle it for you →
Frequently Asked Questions
Quick answers to the most common questions on this topic.
Can a landlord charge a pet deposit for an emotional support animal?
+
Generally no. Under the Fair Housing Act, landlords must provide reasonable accommodations for emotional support animals and cannot charge pet deposits or fees for them. However, the landlord can charge for actual damage caused by the ESA. Provide your ESA documentation (mental health professional letter) to the landlord in writing when you request the accommodation.
I paid a 'non-refundable pet fee' but my state doesn't allow non-refundable deposits. Can I get it back?
+
Possibly. If your state's security deposit law prohibits non-refundable deposits (California is the clearest example), a 'non-refundable pet fee' that functions as a deposit is unenforceable, and you may be entitled to its return. Consult a tenant rights attorney in your state to evaluate whether the charge violates your state's law.
My pet caused significant damage exceeding my pet deposit. What happens?
+
Your pet deposit covers pet-caused damage first. Any remaining damage beyond the pet deposit is charged against your security deposit. Any remaining damage beyond both deposits is still owed to the landlord — they can sue you for this excess in small claims court. Document everything carefully; the extent of 'damage' is often disputed between tenant and landlord.
Can a landlord refuse to rent to me because I have a pet?
+
Yes, for pets generally — a no-pet policy is legal for most animals. However, a landlord cannot refuse to rent to someone with a disability-related service animal or emotional support animal under the FHA. A blanket 'no pets' policy must accommodate service animals and ESAs with proper documentation.
My landlord is keeping my pet deposit even though my cat caused no damage. What do I do?
+
A pet deposit is refundable — it follows the same rules as a regular security deposit. If your cat caused no damage and the landlord is keeping the pet deposit without documentation of actual pet-caused damage, this is wrongful withholding subject to the same remedies (demand letter, small claims court, statutory penalties). Include your move-out photos showing the absence of pet damage in your dispute.