Wage Theft Demand Letter
Tip Theft: When Employers Take or Misuse Employee Tips
Tip theft by employers is illegal under federal law. Learn the rules on tip credits, tip pools, and what to do when your employer is keeping tips that belong to you.
Tips belong to tipped employees under federal law — with specific exceptions for lawful tip pooling arrangements. When employers take tips, pool them with non-tipped employees (managers, supervisors, chefs in traditional settings), or use tips to subsidize non-tipped work, they're committing wage theft. The rules changed significantly with the 2018 FLSA amendments, and understanding the current framework is essential for tipped workers.
At a Glance
Sections
6
FAQs answered
5
Reading time
6 min
Tool available
$39.99
The Fundamental Rule: Tips Belong to Workers
Under the FLSA as amended by the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2018:
The basic rule: Tips are the property of the employees who receive them.
Employers and managers are prohibited from: Keeping any portion of tips received by employees. This applies whether or not the employer takes a tip credit.
The new rule (effective 2018): Even employers who do NOT take a tip credit (i.e., who pay tipped employees full minimum wage) are prohibited from taking any of the employees' tips.
This eliminated the 'pay full minimum wage and keep tips' loophole that some employers had used to structure arrangements where they retained tips because they were paying full minimum wage.
Lawful Tip Pools
Tip pooling allows tips to be distributed among a group of employees rather than kept individually by the worker who received the tip.
If the employer takes a tip credit (pays less than full minimum wage):
- Tips may only be pooled among employees who customarily and regularly receive tips (servers, bartenders, bussers, barbacks, food runners)
- Tips may NOT be shared with kitchen staff, cooks, or dishwashers who don't customarily receive tips
- Managers and supervisors are always excluded
If the employer does NOT take a tip credit (pays full minimum wage):
- Tips may be pooled among a broader group, potentially including kitchen staff and dishwashers
- Still cannot include managers or supervisors
Who counts as a 'supervisor'?: The FLSA defines this based on actual authority, not title. An employee who has genuine authority to hire, fire, and direct work is a supervisor — even if the employer calls them a 'shift lead.'
The 80/20 Rule for Dual Jobs
An employer taking a tip credit can only pay the tipped minimum wage for time the employee is performing tipped work. When tipped employees spend too much time on non-tipped duties, the employer loses the tip credit.
The rule: If a tipped employee spends more than 20% of their time in a workweek on non-tip-producing tasks that support their tipped duties (rolling silverware, cleaning tables when no customers are present, restocking), the employer cannot take the tip credit for those hours.
Examples of non-tipped work that shouldn't exceed 20%:
- Rolling silverware
- Cleaning and stocking the bar between services
- Sweeping floors
- Setting tables before or after service
The violation: If a restaurant manager requires servers to come in an hour early to prep for service (at tipped minimum wage of $2.13/hour) when that prep time represents more than 20% of their shift, the restaurant owes the difference between the tipped minimum wage and the regular minimum wage for those hours.
Credit Card Tips and Service Charges
Credit card processing fees: Employers may deduct credit card processing fees from tips paid by credit card, but the deduction cannot bring the employee's total compensation below minimum wage. The deduction must be proportional to the processing fee actually charged.
Service charges are not tips: When a restaurant adds a mandatory service charge (common for large parties — 'a 20% gratuity will be added for parties of 6 or more'), that service charge belongs to the employer, not the employees — unless the restaurant has a policy of distributing it to workers. This is legal because mandatory service charges are not voluntary tips.
The confusion: Many diners assume service charges go to their server. If your employer retains service charges and your pay doesn't reflect them, that's the employer's right with mandatory service charges (but deceptive marketing — inform customers). However, if they use service charges in a way that affects your tip credit calculations, there may be wage issues.
Common Tip Theft Violations to Watch For
Manager taking cash from the tip jar: Direct theft. Managers may not take any portion of tips.
Requiring service charges to be 'donated' back to the restaurant: If the restaurant requires employees to surrender tips or service charges as part of a 'donation' arrangement, that's tip theft.
Pooling tips with managers or supervisors: Even if the supervisor also serves customers sometimes, if they have genuine managerial authority, they cannot participate in the tip pool.
'Tipout' to kitchen staff when the employer uses tip credit: If your employer pays you below minimum wage using the tip credit, the pool cannot include kitchen staff who don't customarily receive tips.
Technology-platform fee as tip cut: Some point-of-sale systems or delivery platforms take a percentage of tips. This may be permissible for the platform fee portion but not for amounts beyond legitimate fees.
Recovering Stolen Tips
Department of Labor complaint: File with the WHD at dol.gov/agencies/whd. Tip violations are among the most common WHD investigations in the restaurant industry.
State labor agency: Most states have tip protection laws in addition to federal law. Some states have stronger protections.
Private FLSA lawsuit: Bring a claim directly in federal district court. Tip theft that violates FLSA allows recovery of lost tips, liquidated damages (equal to the lost tips), and attorney fees.
Class action: Tip pool violations typically affect all tipped employees. A collective action can multiply the impact.
Statute of limitations: 2 years for non-willful; 3 years for willful violations under the FLSA.
The 2018 penalty: The FLSA as amended in 2018 added civil money penalties of up to $1,100 per violation for employers who take tips — in addition to the back tips and liquidated damages.
Frequently Asked Questions
Quick answers to the most common questions on this topic.
Can my manager participate in the tip pool?
+
No. Managers and supervisors are categorically excluded from tip pools under the 2018 FLSA amendments. This applies whether or not the employer takes a tip credit. If your manager takes a portion of the tip pool, file a complaint with the DOL.
My employer takes a percentage of credit card tips for 'processing.' Is that legal?
+
Only to the extent of the actual processing fee charged by the credit card company — typically 2–3%. If your employer is keeping 5% for 'processing' when the actual fee is 2%, they're keeping your tips illegally.
What if I earn below minimum wage even after tips?
+
If your total compensation (cash wage plus tips) in any workweek falls below minimum wage, your employer must make up the difference immediately. If they don't, they've violated both the tip credit rules and minimum wage law.
Can a restaurant add a mandatory service charge and keep all of it?
+
Yes — mandatory service charges are the employer's property, not tips. However, the employer may not count the service charge toward the tip credit (it's not a tip). If customers believe the charge goes to the server and it doesn't, that's a truth-in-advertising issue — not an FLSA violation, though some states have enacted specific disclosure requirements.
I work at a tip-pooled establishment. How do I know if the pool is legal?
+
Check who participates in the pool. If your employer takes the tip credit: only customarily tipped employees (servers, bartenders, bussers, barbacks) can participate — not kitchen staff or managers. If the employer pays full minimum wage: kitchen staff can participate but not managers. If you're contributing to a pool that includes managers or supervisors, that's illegal.