Contractor Dispute Letter
Your Rights When You Hired an Unlicensed Contractor
Hired a contractor who turns out to be unlicensed? You may have more legal options than you think. Learn what unlicensed contracting means for your dispute and recovery options.
Discovering your contractor is unlicensed after a dispute begins can dramatically shift the legal landscape in your favor. In most states, unlicensed contractors have limited legal rights and you may have enhanced remedies. But the picture is nuanced — here's what it actually means for your situation.
At a Glance
Sections
6
FAQs answered
5
Reading time
5 min
Tool available
$49.99
What Contractor Licensing Requires
Contractor licensing requirements vary by state and trade:
States with comprehensive licensing: California, Florida, Texas, Nevada, and most others require general contractors and specialty contractors to be licensed at the state level.
What licensing involves (typically):
- Passing a knowledge examination
- Proof of experience
- Carrying workers' compensation insurance
- Carrying general liability insurance
- Posting a surety bond
- Background check
The licensing purpose: Licensing protects consumers by ensuring contractors have minimum competency, are insured against injuries and property damage, and have a bond that can compensate consumers for non-performance.
Trade-specific licensing: Electricians, plumbers, HVAC technicians, roofers, and other specialty trades often require separate licenses in addition to a general contractor's license. Even a licensed general contractor may use unlicensed specialty subcontractors.
How to Verify a Contractor's License
Before hiring (ideally) and when disputes arise:
- Find your state's contractor licensing board: Search '[state name] contractor license lookup' or CSLB (California), DBPR (Florida), TDLR (Texas), etc.
- Enter the contractor's name or license number: Check that the license is active, not expired, not suspended
- Verify the license type: Does the license they have cover the work they're doing for you?
- Check for disciplinary actions: Most licensing boards show complaint history
California example: The CSLB's license check tool at cslb.ca.gov shows license status, bond information, workers' comp coverage, and any disciplinary history.
If you can't find the license: That's a strong indicator they're unlicensed. Contractors must have their license number on their contracts, vehicles, advertisements, and communications in most states.
What Unlicensed Status Means for Your Legal Dispute
The legal consequences of a contractor's unlicensed status depend significantly on your state:
California (strictest):
- Unlicensed contractors cannot legally sue to collect payment
- All compensation paid to an unlicensed contractor may be recoverable
- California law (B&P Code § 7031) allows you to recover all compensation paid to an unlicensed contractor, even if the work was done properly
- This is not a punishment for the work quality — it's a blanket rule about unlicensed practice
Other states with similar rules: Arizona, Nevada, Florida have provisions limiting unlicensed contractor rights
States with more nuanced rules: Some states distinguish between work requiring licensing and work that doesn't; between partial and complete license requirements; and between technical violations and substantive licensing failures
The general principle in most states: An unlicensed contractor cannot sue for the contract price, but you can still sue them for breach of contract and damages if work was performed poorly.
Your Enhanced Remedies Against Unlicensed Contractors
Against an unlicensed contractor, you may have:
Full refund of all payments made (California and similar states): Under B&P Code § 7031, even if work was done, you can sue for disgorgement of all fees paid because the contract is void for unlicensed practice.
Criminal reporting: Unlicensed contracting is a misdemeanor or felony in most states. Reporting to your state licensing board and local law enforcement creates pressure and may result in prosecution.
No lien rights: In most states, unlicensed contractors cannot file or enforce a mechanic's lien. If a lien has been filed by an unlicensed contractor, this is grounds to discharge the lien.
Consumer protection act claims: Many states' consumer protection acts (UDAP statutes) specifically cover unlicensed contractor fraud — providing treble damages, attorney fees, and other enhanced remedies.
No right to payment for substandard work: Even in states without California-style disgorgement, an unlicensed contractor who did substandard work faces the dual problems of unlicensed practice liability AND breach of contract/negligence claims.
Homeowner Responsibility: What You Should Have Known
Some defenses are available to unlicensed contractors in certain circumstances:
If you knew the contractor was unlicensed: In California, the disgorgement rule is limited if you knew the contractor was unlicensed (and in some cases if you were a business, not an individual homeowner).
The 'substantial compliance' defense: Some states allow unlicensed contractors to recover if they were in substantial compliance with licensing requirements and obtained a license before or shortly after the work.
Work not requiring a license: Not all contracting work requires licensing. Handyman work, landscaping (in some states), and minor repairs may not require a license. An unlicensed contractor doing only work that doesn't require a license may not be in violation.
Your exposure: As a homeowner, your main exposure in unlicensed contractor situations is workers' compensation liability. If an unlicensed contractor's worker is injured on your property, and the contractor has no workers' comp insurance (which licensed contractors must carry), you may be liable as the 'employer.'
Practical Steps When Your Contractor Is Unlicensed
- Verify unlicensed status through the state licensing board — get documentation
- Stop all further payments — you have leverage and paying more reduces your net recovery
- Document the project status: Photos of work done, work not done
- Demand a refund in writing: Reference the unlicensed status and applicable law
- Report to the state licensing board: File a formal complaint
- Consult an attorney: In California and similar states, the legal right to disgorgement is powerful; an attorney can file a quick demand or complaint and often recovers quickly
- File in small claims court for amounts within limits
- Chargeback credit card payments if paid by card
Don't let the contractor know you've discovered their unlicensed status before you've stopped further payments and documented everything. Some unscrupulous contractors use this window to file fraudulent liens.
Frequently Asked Questions
Quick answers to the most common questions on this topic.
Can an unlicensed contractor sue me for unpaid work?
+
In many states, including California, unlicensed contractors cannot sue for unpaid work — the contract is void. In other states, they can sue but you have significant defenses. Knowing your state's specific rule is critical when an unlicensed contractor makes demands.
What if the work was done well — can I still get a refund because they were unlicensed?
+
In California, yes — B&P Code § 7031 allows full disgorgement even if the work quality was acceptable. The policy purpose is to deter unlicensed contracting broadly, not to punish bad work specifically.
What if I hired a licensed contractor but they used unlicensed subcontractors?
+
Your contract is with the licensed GC, who is responsible for their subcontractors. The unlicensed sub issue creates problems for the GC (potentially affecting their license) and may give you breach of contract claims against the GC, but your primary legal relationship is with the licensed contractor.
Will homeowner's insurance cover damage caused by an unlicensed contractor?
+
Possibly — check your policy. Some policies exclude coverage for work done by unlicensed contractors, or may deny claims if you knowingly hired an unlicensed contractor. The workers' compensation gap (your potential liability if an unlicensed worker is injured) is typically not covered by standard homeowner's policies.
How do I find out if my contractor's license is valid?
+
Search your state's contractor licensing board database with the contractor's name or license number. Verify the license is active, the type covers the work being done, and there are no pending disciplinary actions.